On Free Will and Compassion Within A Defined System
A while back,
I started to question agency and free will.
It was born from trauma and pain,
And the question—
Why?
Why do we hurt each other?
Why are some more broken than others?
Why would someone who has free will
Choose to hurt others?
I started to wonder—
What makes us who we are?
Is it more than what behavioral science has offered?
If so many things out of our control
Shape who we are, what we like, what we believe—
Do we really make meaningful decisions?
Is it even possible
To have free will and agency?
If God is real,
And He assigns us our lives—
Would anyone want to be a bad person,
Or to be hurt?
Would a being with free will and agency
Choose a life without love or happiness?
I don’t think so.
But it’s not black and white.
And the universe can contradict.
I see it as both—
That we have free will and agency,
And yet we are formed
By things largely out of our control.
We are like a roleplaying game
With premade characters.
We exist in a defined system and character—
But what we do with that character is up to us.
And we have the ability to learn,
To grow,
To change.
This belief does not enslave me.
It frees me.
I am who I am,
And I can change—
But I have to be given the opportunity.
The tools must be accessible.
I have found greater compassion and empathy
In this belief.
Deserve isn’t what matters.
What matters
Is that all are given the opportunity to change.
It doesn’t make life lose meaning.
It allows us
To make our own meaning.
It doesn’t absolve or rid us
Of personal responsibility.
It allows us
To make meaningful change
Within the system.
And for those who are unable to change—
Because of issues within themselves
They did not ask for—
We can have empathy
And compassion for them,
While still protecting ourselves
And each other.
We were all created—
Whether by God or science—
Within the same system.
And so,
We can choose to understand each other,
And offer love
Where we can.
Love and harm are born from the same place.
They are part of who we are.
But within the system,
We all have the ability to change.
With opportunity and the right tools,
We decide who we become.